Macanudo Sumatra Cigar Reviews
Cigar Reviewed:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
San Antonio, TX
The Macanudo Sumatra surprised me in a good way. While Macanudo is often associated with milder cigars, this one brings a little more richness and complexity without losing the smoothness…
Cigar Reviewed:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
Plain City, Ohio
I don't have the refined palate to detect things like "pepper, leather and notes of Umami" and whatnot. I just know when I like a smoke. This is one of…
Cigar Reviewed:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
Chicago, IL
The construction was good. Flavor was excellent for some reason after about 5 min I had to relight. I was outside in the hot heat so that may have affected…
Cigar Reviewed:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
Topeka. KS
This stick is wholesomely delicious from match to tray. It delivers a well-rounded smoking profile highlighted by notes of cedar, cocoa, coffee, and roasted nuts. Loved it!
Cigar Reviewed:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
Home
Very smooth and great draw. Also has a great burn. Will rate 8 out of 10
Cigar Reviewed:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
New York
I thought it was a very nice cigar flavor
Cigar Reviewed:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
Crossville, TN
The aroma alone won me over on this beauty! The rich wrapper added an indulgent taste and aroma that was not anywhere near what was expected of this beauty. Nice,…
Cigar Reviewed:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
Michigan
Very full body smoke. Great burn till the last 3rd of the cigar. Kept running on me. Still able to finish but had to keep touching it up.
Cigar Reviewed:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
My home
This is the first of the 2 I received to test unfortunately time was not on its side, wasn't able to give this stick a proper rest before smoking, and…
Cigar Reviewed:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
Detroit
Very pleasant pre-light aroma. The Sumatra wrapper seems to grab your attention and keep it throughout the cigar. It will be on my list to stock up on.
Cigar Reviewed:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
Tennessee
Macanudo Testing Lab – Sumatra Review
Overall Rating: 8.7/10
A Sumatra That Sinatra Would Love
*“Like a good Sinatra tune, this cigar didn’t rely on flashy notes or dramatic changes. Instead, it delivered…
Cigar Reviewed:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
Home
The Introduction & Pre-Light Macanudo has long been the king of the approachable Connecticut shade, but the Macanudo Sumatra proves they know how to step into darker territory without losing…
Cigar Reviewed:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
Long Beach, Mississippi
Macanudo Sumatra
Cigar World Testing Lab Review
Disclosure: This cigar was provided by the Cigar World Testing Lab for review. Because of the Testing Lab’s timeline, it rested in my humidor for…
Cigar Reviewed:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
Fredericksburg VA
Just finished the Macanudo Sumatra, and I’d definitely smoke it again. Super smooth with notes of cocoa, coffee, cedar, and a little spice. The draw was great, the burn stayed…
Cigar Reviewed:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
Bensalem Pa
Tight draw using a punch but a boatload of flavor. Coffee ,cocoa and spice
Cigar Reviewed: Macanudo Sumatra
The Sumatra is an excellent addition to the Macanudo profile yhe cigar is a nice medium and approachable smoke for beginners and aficionados. First light is nice and earthy in…
Cigar Reviewed:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
The Abode
Boy, I wasn’t expecting such a nice cigar for the price. Attractive, with a tight, solid wrapper and a nice binder. The taste starts smooth and creamy, then transitions to…
Cigar Reviewed:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
Front porch
It’s a pleasant cigar but I prefer a cigar with more strength!
Cigar Reviewed:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
Front porch.
Tasty cigar with a respectable retrohale, and a nice price point! Enjoyable.
Smoked:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
Peoria Illinois
Cigar Reviewed:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
Peoria Illinois
An interesting smoke that inspires a large ring guage to try the “gordo”6-60.
I love medium-full strength and strong profile of this blend look forward to trying more from the #CigarWorldTestingLab.
Cigar Reviewed:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
Loganville, Georgia
Got my first two cigars from the Testing Lab. Smoked the Sumatra and found flavors of expresso, malt, and cedar. Even burn, no relights. When this has some humi time…
Cigar Reviewed:
Macanudo Sumatra
Smoked at:
Home 5016 West Beloit Road WEST MILWAUKEE Wisconsin
Just enjoyed the Sumatra with my morning coffee and it went great. Nice slow burn and very mellow.
Cigar Reviewed: Macanudo Sumatra
The Macanudo Sumatra Robusto starts with a nice caramel note that quickly turns into dark coffee, bitter chocolate, and roasted nuts. It’s box-pressed, medium-bodied, smooth at first, and has an…
