Top Rated Mellow Cigars For 2025

The Top-Rated Mellow Cigars for 2025

Sometimes, you just want to take it easy. If you’re in the mood for a mellow cigar, you’re in the right place. While mellow cigars are occasionally classed as “beginner cigars,” the truth is that cigars with lighter wrappers and mellower bodies can still impart tons of flavor and produce extraordinary smoking experiences. So whether you’re a newbie or a long-time cigar lover, you’ll find some excellent recommendations on our list of the top-rated mellow cigars for 2025. 

Macanudo Café

Individually handcrafted, Macanudo Café is a mellow, distinctively smooth cigar that’s incredibly easy to smoke. In addition to being a consumer favorite, Macanudo Café has been endorsed by Cigar Insider (a sister publication to Cigar Aficionado) with a rating of 90. And this was the cigar that practically put Connecticut Shade cigars on the map. Start your mellow cigar journey here.

Wrapper: Connecticut Shade

Binder: Mexican San Andrean

Filler: Mexican, Dominican Piloto Cubano

Cohiba Connecticut

Cohiba Connecticut is an upscale premium cigar, with each puff delivering mellow, smooth, silky, and wonderfully nutty notes. You’ll also enjoy hints of sweet cream, cedar, earth, and wood. Undoubtedly, it’s a luxury smoke worth picking up for a special occasion.

Wrapper: Ecuadorian Connecticut

Binder: Mexican

Filler: Brazilian, Dominican, Nicaraguan

Illusione Candela

Candelas are always visually striking, but they also deliver distinctively grassy, creamy, and delightfully mellow flavor profiles at their best. One of our favorites is this green classic from Illusione. Expect floral notes with hints of leather and sweetness throughout this eye-catching smoke!

Wrapper: Nicaraguan (Candela)

Binder: Nicaraguan

Filler: Nicaraguan

Davidoff Grand Cru

Immediately impressive, Davidoff Grand Cru is a seamless, mellow cigar that boasts an attention-grabbing, light-golden Ecuadorian Connecticut Shade wrapper. Inside, you’ll find a delectable blend of Dominican tobaccos that gives way to a bouquet of complex flavors, including spice, cedar, and an overall sweetness.

Wrapper: Ecuadorian Connecticut Shade

Binder: Dominican

Filler: Dominican

Montecristo Original

Known for its smooth and satisfying taste, Montecristo Original is a medium-bodied cigar dressed in an impeccably constructed, golden brown Connecticut Shade wrapper. Thoughtfully tucked inside, you’ll find a blend of Dominican tobaccos that give way to notes of white pepper and cream.

Wrapper: Connecticut Shade

Binder: Dominican

Filler: Dominican

E.P. Carillo Encore

While most of the cigars on this list feature some type of Connecticut Shade wrapper, the truth is that “dark” cigars can also have suave, mellower profiles, too. If you’re in the market for a cigar with a little more oomph than your average Connecticut Shade smoke, look no further than E.P. Carillo Encore. Smooth and rich, this Nicaraguan puro isn’t the mellowest cigar on our list, but it’s a great transition cigar for those looking to expand their portfolio. 

Wrapper: Nicaraguan

Binder: Nicaraguan

Filler: Nicaraguan

CAO Gold

Introduced in 1996, CAO Gold continues to enjoy a devoted fan base and has received some of the highest ratings in the industry, including multiple 90 ratings from various sources. This cigar features a gorgeous Ecuadorian Connecticut seed wrapper along with a well-aged Nicaraguan binder and filler.

Wrapper: Ecuadorian Connecticut

Binder: Nicaraguan 

Filler: Nicaraguan

Oliva Connecticut Reserve

Connecticut Reserve by Oliva is a rich, mellow cigar that boasts a golden-brown Ecuadorian Connecticut Shade wrapper draped over a meticulously blended bunch of Nicaraguan tobaccos. Silky smooth from start to finish, enjoy notes of wood, coffee, and cream in each and every puff.

Wrapper: Ecuadorian Connecticut Shade

Binder: Nicaraguan

Filler: Nicaraguan

Rocky Patel The Edge Connecticut

The Edge Connecticut by Rocky Patel is an extremely well-balanced and dazzling mellow cigar. It hits the scene dressed in a golden-brown Connecticut Shade wrapper that’s as smooth as it is good-looking. On the inside, a meticulously aged blend of Honduran, Nicaraguan, and Mexican San Andres tobaccos generates complex notes of citrus, spice, and cream with a floral finish.

Wrapper: Connecticut Shade

Binder: Mexican San Andres

Filler: Honduran, Nicaraguan

What’s your favorite mellow cigar? Sign up for Cigar World and let us know in the comments!