My Father The Judge Cigar Reviews

Reviews

Smoked: My Father The Judge
Smoked at: Fume, Fairfield, NJ

Smoking the My Father The Judge. Reliable good smoke. Haven’t smoked one in a few years. My palate changed a while back, however, I’m now enjoying some old time favorites

Read More

Member Avatar

Wow Factor

by 3 Stevekepl

Cigar Reviewed: My Father The Judge

Initial Light and First Third:

When you first light up "The Judge", you'll likely be greeted with a burst of peppery spice. This is a signature of many Nicaraguan cigars, especially

Read More

Rating:

Cigar Reviewed: My Father The Judge

Great mild-medium bodied smoke. Great burn. This stick should always be in your humidor.

Read More

Rating:

Cigar Reviewed: My Father The Judge
Smoked at: Fairbanks, AK

Synopsis: They need to rename this stick The Fudge.

The Cigar handshake:

At first you're greeted with 2 beautiful bands proudly showing the My Father logo and the name of the cigar,

Read More

Rating:

Member Avatar

Great smoke

by 2 Grim

Cigar Reviewed: My Father The Judge

Slow burn, full ish body. Enjoyable. Would buy again. 4.5/5.

Read More

Rating:

Cigar Reviewed: My Father The Judge
Smoked at: Fort Worth Tx

At first light spicy and your thinking your in for a ride then after first third your smooth out and are able to take your seatbelts off and move about

Read More

Rating:

Cigar Reviewed: My Father The Judge

This was my first MF cigar. Maybe it was an oddball, after sitting on my humidor for a few weeks I notice a crack in the middle. I tried my

Read More

Rating:

Smoked: My Father The Judge
Smoked at: Ocean Isle Beach NC

What an absolute flavor bomb! Straight no none sense flavor bomb!

Read More

Member Avatar

Fantastic

by 100 Big Paulie

Cigar Reviewed: My Father The Judge
Smoked at: Staten Island

**To say This is a great stick is an understatement! Cold draw sweet hay chocolate espresso. 1/3 black pepper spice espresso dark chocolate. 2/3 easy draw great smooth medium to

Read More

Rating:

Member Avatar

Super!

by 66 Rob21

Cigar Reviewed: My Father The Judge

These are a great smoke, burn, flavors and aroma!

Read More

Rating:

Cigar Reviewed: My Father The Judge
Smoked at: Republic, MO

Country: Nicaragua

Wrapper: Ecuador Sumatra

Cinnamon-hued Ecuador Sumatra wrappers cover a full-bodied recipe of select Nicaraguan tobaccos grown on Garcia family estates. Taste a magnificent profile of leather, cedar, nuts and signature

Read More

Rating:

Cigar Reviewed: My Father The Judge
Smoked at: Republic, MO

Flawless! Full bodied and spicy! Slight box press, begins a little uneven on the burn-but quickly self corrects. This is for someone looking for a nicely rounded full flavor experience!

Read More

Rating:

Member Avatar

Fantastic smoke

by 1 Jason3537

Cigar Reviewed: My Father The Judge

This cigar is a go to of mine. I particularly like the box pressed version of this cigar. If you are looking for a smooth full flavored smoke this one

Read More

Rating:

Member Avatar

Very Nice cigar!

by 1 Big B

Cigar Reviewed: My Father The Judge
Smoked at: Summerville, SC

Well balanced notes of earth, leather, with a slight sweetness! Strong beginning 1/3 that became more smooth afterwards. Even burn and a plethora of flavor throughout!

Read More

Rating: