My Father The Judge Cigar Reviews
Cigar Reviewed: My Father The Judge
Great draw. I picked up the leather and pepper notes. After the first third, the flavor changed for me and it became a nutter flavor, which I enjoyed. Definitely on…
Cigar Reviewed:
My Father The Judge
Smoked at:
Southampton, NY
I tried this not knowing a lot about My Father. On the recommendation of my tobacconist who knows my preferences, I gave it a go.. Construction, draw and flavor notes…
Cigar Reviewed:
My Father The Judge
Smoked at:
Diebel's Sportmens Gallery - 426 Ward Pkwy, Kansas City, MO 64112
This cigar smoked well but uneven, the body was great but the flavor left a little to be desired. Overall a good smoke.
Cigar Reviewed:
My Father The Judge
Smoked at:
The Humidor - Sherman - 2612 N. Loy Lake Rd., Suite 210, Sherman, TX 75090
Great Stick
Cigar Reviewed: My Father The Judge
My Father The Judge Toro
Excellent stick. I can't say it enough, but when the construction and draw is perfect on a cigar, it makes it so much easier to enjoy...and…
Smoked: My Father The Judge
Happy Father’s Day. This is a great cigar. Great construction, it burns a nice ash. Very good aroma and taste. Nice bit of spice and it pairs very well with…
Cigar Reviewed: My Father The Judge
This is a great cigar. Great construction, it burns a nice ash. Very good aroma and taste. Nice bit of spice and it pairs very well with the espresso martini…
Smoked: My Father The Judge
I’m enjoying the long weekend with a rum & sod with The Judge. The smoke is very good with a bit of spice that increases as you smoke. Very good…
Cigar Reviewed:
My Father The Judge
Smoked at:
Iwan Ries & Co - 19 S Wabash Ave, Suite 200, Chicago, IL 60603
I absolutely understand why this was the best cigar of 2024. A wonderful, relaxing smoke from start to finish. It holds incredibly well during the smoke. It has a nice…
Smoked: My Father The Judge
Happy New Year. To start the New Year out right, I decided to pick the highest rated cigar that I had in the humidor. The Judge definitely earned its stripes.…
Cigar Reviewed:
My Father The Judge
Smoked at:
Houston
Nutty
Oak
Slight pepper flavor with the 2/3
Smooth draw and a savory smoke.
Cigar Reviewed:
My Father The Judge
Smoked at:
Norfolk lounge
Awesome smoke! Enjoyed this today before work. Smoke was smooth and mellow. Had tasting notes of nuts and noticed a little bit of a salty flavor about half through. Would…
Cigar Reviewed: My Father The Judge
To me, this stick is the grandfather of cigars! Amazing body and full flavor. Notes of Dark chocolate, earth and almond finish. A great cigar to end the day with!
Cigar Reviewed:
My Father The Judge
Smoked at:
Blacksburg, Virginia
My Father The Judge Toro Fino (6 x 52) Wonderfully crafted cigar you will never go wrong with anything made by José and Jaime Garcia. The construction and flavor profiles…
Smoked:
My Father The Judge
Smoked at:
NW NJ
One of the best cigars I have enjoyed this year. Box pressed Toro 6X52 with Ecuador Sumatra wrapper and Nicaraguan filler and binder.Cedar and coffee or maybe espresso along with…
Smoked:
My Father The Judge
Smoked at:
West Chester, Ohio
My Father The Judge is a Garcia Nicaraguan tobacco blend covered in a slightly oily box pressed chocolate brown Ecuador Sumatra wrapper.
Wood and pepper are dominant, but there are notes…
Smoked:
My Father The Judge
Smoked at:
Colorado springs
Smoked:
My Father The Judge
Smoked at:
Fume, Fairfield, NJ
Smoking the My Father The Judge. Reliable good smoke. Haven’t smoked one in a few years. My palate changed a while back, however, I’m now enjoying some old time favorites…
Cigar Reviewed: My Father The Judge
Initial Light and First Third:
When you first light up "The Judge", you'll likely be greeted with a burst of peppery spice. This is a signature of many Nicaraguan cigars, especially…
Cigar Reviewed: My Father The Judge
Great mild-medium bodied smoke. Great burn. This stick should always be in your humidor.
Cigar Reviewed:
My Father The Judge
Smoked at:
Fairbanks, AK
Synopsis: They need to rename this stick The Fudge.
The Cigar handshake:
At first you're greeted with 2 beautiful bands proudly showing the My Father logo and the name of the cigar,…
Cigar Reviewed: My Father The Judge
Slow burn, full ish body. Enjoyable. Would buy again. 4.5/5.
1 2