# My Father The Judge Review #37 by Goomba

The Judge starts out with pepper and carries it all the way through. About a third of the way you can pick up some dark chocolate. This is a full bodied smoke with very good aroma. By Goomba on December 21 2025 5:10:35 PM

- **Cigar:** [My Father The Judge](https://www.cigarworld.com/cigars/my-father/the-judge/)
- **Reviewed by:** Goomba
- **Date:** December 21, 2025
- **Rating:** 4 out of 5
- **Body:** 5 out of 5
- **Flavor:** 4 out of 5
- **Construction:** 4 out of 5
- **Smoked at:** My Patio

## A Very Good Smoke

The Judge starts out with pepper and carries it all the way through. About a third of the way you can pick up some dark chocolate. This is a full bodied smoke with very good aroma. The construction is very good, nice draw, even burn line and it holds a nice ash. It pairs very well with scotch.